There’d been several unflattering comments and newspaper reports on the recently concluded Singapore Idol competition. To me, both singers deserved to be in the final and it didn’t matter to me who won because they are both good, so congrats to Sezairi for pipping Sylvia to the crown.
I believe Sylvia lost it with her choice of “Yellow” as her second song. ST described her performance of the song as “tepid” and it’s exactly the word I’d use as well. Seasoned contestants of singing competitions - especially one where the audience decides the outcome - would know that their song choice must satisfy the audience and not pander to the contestant’s liking. In other words, they should choose a song that would please the general public and not simply one that they - the contestants - like or enjoy singing. Yes, it’s strategic but look where it took Sezairi. Sezairi basically nudged ahead of the game with his rendition of “Crazy” and then nailed it with “Touched by an Angel”.
In the end, based solely on the performances in the final, Sezairi is a worthy winner. Sorry, Sylvia. What surprised me, though, were some unusual coments from Sylvia’s supporters. Some said they voted for Sylvia because they wanted a “change” by voting in a female Idol. Hmm….that is NOT a good enough reason to make Sylvia win, I’m afraid. I mean, if she were to be the first female winner of Singapore Idol, I’m sure she would want to win it on her own merits….and not because she is female. Another comment made by the press was how Sezairi becomes the third Singapore Idol winner with an R&B influence. And what’s wrong with that? If Singapore likes his sound, why not? It just proves how much R&B appeals to the general music public. I doubt a rocker or dare I even suggest a country singer would be as widely appreciated in a Singapore Idol final….if they got that far.
While the call for more variety in the next season is probably welcome, it really depends on whether the really talented Singaporeans would be motivated enough to take part. [I have no doubt there are many talented singers among us] Perhaps the producers of Singapore Idol should consider increasing the prize money.
Joe




